I purchased these in two colours that matched lipsticks I had. The reason I choose these over pencils is that I liked that I didn't need to sharpen them, and I'm the kind of person that always forgets where I put my cosmetic sharpener (and I have 3 of then floating around).
The pigment was fairly average, but as it was just to stop the lip colour bleeding, that didn't both me too much. The reason I wouldn't buy them again was due to their short wear time. I would say I would have to reapply hourly, which is just not ideal.
So nice colours, but don't wear well.
This is great basic lipliner which for me lasts well and extends the life of my lipstick. The nude shade works under any shade of lipstick that I wear and is great for intensifying nude lipstick. The price point is good value considering that this liner lasts me for several months (wearing 5-6 days each week).
Tips: Apply over the entire lips to prolong the life of your lipstick